Decoding the EB-1A High Pay Criterion: Is Your Salary Extraordinary Enough to Qualify?

If you've consistently earned a significantly higher salary or compensation compared to others in your field, this criterion could be a key component of your successful EB-1A petition.

Understanding the "High Pay" Criterion for EB-1A

The EB-1A visa is reserved for individuals who have demonstrated extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics. To qualify, you must meet at least three of the ten specific criteria outlined by USCIS. One of these criteria focuses on proving that you have commanded a high salary or other remuneration for your services, significantly higher than that of others in your field.

This isn't just about earning a good living; it's about showcasing that your unique skills and contributions have been recognized and rewarded financially at an exceptional level within your profession.

How to Assess Your High Pay Potential: The OFLC Wage Data Method

When I'm first evaluating a client's potential for the high pay criterion, my initial step is to look at the OFLC Wage Data. This is the same wage data used for H-1B visas and is a reliable tool for establishing prevailing wages in various occupations across different geographic areas.

Here's how you can begin to assess your own position:

1. Identify Your Occupation Classification: If you're currently an H-1B worker, you can find your specific occupation classification code on your Labor Condition Application (LCA). This code will ensure you're comparing apples to apples. For example, my occupation as a lawyer is coded as 23-1011.
2. Access the OFLC Wage Search: Head over to the OFLC Wage Search website, which is run by the Department of Labor. https://flag.dol.gov/wage-data/wage-search
3. Enter Your Details: Input your occupation code and select your specific county or metropolitan area.
4. Review the Wage Data: The system will display four wage levels (Level 1, 2, 3, and 4) and the mean wage for your occupation in your chosen metropolitan area.

What You're Looking For

When analyzing this data, your goal is to demonstrate a history of earning comfortably above the Level 4 wage and significantly higher than the mean wage for your occupation in your specific metropolitan area.

It's crucial to understand that USCIS doesn't have a fixed dollar amount that guarantees approval. What constitutes "high pay" is relative to your specific occupation and the economic landscape of your metropolitan area. A salary that's extraordinary in one city might be considered average in another, or for a different profession. And certainly that's true from one occupation to another.

Beyond Just Numbers: What Truly Qualifies as "High Remuneration"?

While a strong base salary is the starting point, your total compensation package often tells a fuller story of your value.

• Considering Total Compensation: If you have executive compensation summaries, expected earnings reports, or documentation showing stock options and bonus structures, these can be a huge positive. They illustrate the full scope of your financial recognition.
• Navigating USCIS Scrutiny: However, it's important to be aware that USCIS sometimes scrutinizes these types of earnings. I've seen instances where adjudicators might discount stock options or bonuses, arguing that these weren't necessarily based on your direct, regular work, but perhaps on overall company performance or a specific bonus structure.

Navigating Common Pitfalls: The Occupation vs. Job Title Conundrum

One of the most common challenges we encounter when proving the high pay criterion is USCIS misinterpreting your occupation or nitpicking the data you provide. Adjudicators often get confused between a broad "occupation" and a specific "job title."

Let me give you an example: If your job title is "Partner" at a law firm, that's what you're called internally. However, "Partner" isn't an occupation with its own distinct wage data in the OFLC system, and it doesn't establish whether you're a lawyer, or a management consultant, or something else entirely. Your underlying occupation is "Lawyer."

The Request for Evidence (RFE) Trap

It's unfortunately not uncommon for USCIS to issue a Request for Evidence (RFE) for EB1A petition about this criterion. The adjudicator may claim that you've used the wrong data or misclassified your occupation. You'll then have to re-argue the point, clearly explaining that "Partner" in your context refers to a "Lawyer," and provide additional documentation (like O*NET classifications) to link your title to the recognized occupation.

Bridging the Knowledge Gap

Remember, while these distinctions might seem obvious to you within your specialized field, the USCIS adjudicator reviews cases across a vast array of industries and professions. They don't possess the same subject matter expertise, familiarity with your specific industry's nuances, or an understanding of normal career progression in your company or field.

This is where our job as your immigration attorney becomes critical. It's your lawyer's responsibility to lay out your case in a simple, digestible, and undeniable way. It needs to be abundantly clear to the adjudicator that your earnings are indeed extraordinary compared to others performing similar work to yours.

My Role as Your Immigration Attorney

Successfully leveraging the high pay criterion for your EB-1A petition requires more than just presenting numbers. It demands meticulous attention to detail, a strategic approach to evidence presentation, and the ability to anticipate and proactively address potential questions or misunderstandings from USCIS.

I help clients gather the right documentation, interpret wage data accurately, and craft compelling arguments that demonstrate how their exceptional compensation truly reflects their extraordinary abilities. We work together to ensure your case is not just strong, but crystal clear, leaving no room for misinterpretation.

Conclusion

The EB-1A high pay criterion is a compelling way to demonstrate your extraordinary ability, offering a direct path to a green card for individuals whose exceptional skills are recognized through their remuneration. While straightforward in concept, its application can be nuanced, requiring careful analysis, precise data presentation, and a deep understanding of USCIS expectations.

By thoroughly analyzing your compensation against relevant wage data and preparing your case to preemptively address potential challenges, you significantly enhance your chances of success. I'm here to help you showcase your extraordinary contributions effectively and unlock your path to permanent residency in the U.S.

---
Locke Immigration Law helps American companies and immigrant professinals work together.

Send us your information to see if we can help you.

Follow Loren Locke on LinkedIn

Watch Loren Locke on YouTube

---

Want to learn how to strategically frame your achievements for the EB1A "Extraordinary Ability" visa?

My free 5-day email course, "5 Days to Your Compelling EB1A Story," provides the 'EB1A Storytelling Toolkit' to help you build a powerful case.

Sign up here: https://lockeimmigration.com/eb1a-email-course