EB-1A & NIW Recommendation Letters: How Many Do You Really Need?

Clients who are pursuing an EB-1A Extraordinary Ability petition, an O-1, or a National Interest Waiver (NIW) always want to know one main thing about recommendation letters: "How many do I need?"

It's a great question, and like most things in immigration law, the answer isn't a simple, fixed number. There's no magic threshold that guarantees approval.

Is There a Magic Number for Recommendation Letters?

The ideal quantity of recommendation letters for your EB-1A or NIW petition depends on your individual circumstances. My primary goal when preparing your petition is to present a comprehensive and compelling narrative of your career and accomplishments.

Factors That Determine the Ideal Number of Letters

When I evaluate how many letters you might need, I consider several key factors:

• Telling Your Unique Career Story: Think about how many different people are necessary to fully illustrate your career's progression and impact. Each recommender should add a unique perspective or cover a specific period or achievement.
• Your Career Trajectory & Longevity:
  • Diverse Experience: Have you worked at one organization throughout your career, or have you moved between ten different companies, projects, or institutions? A more varied career might require more letters to cover all significant phases and contributions.
  • Career Length: Are you 30 years old, or are you 60? A longer career often means more accomplishments, more roles, and more people who can speak to your extraordinary abilities over time. We want to tell the story from your college days right up to the present.
• The "Diminishing Returns" Factor: While comprehensive, we also need to be mindful of the adjudicator reviewing your case. USCIS officers have limited time, patience, and attention to spend on any single filing.
  • Content vs. Quantity: There's a point of diminishing returns. If you include more letters than you have unique content or new perspectives to share, the impact of each individual letter lessens. And it looks terrible if they all appear to be written by the same person!
  • Readability: Consider the sheer volume of your filing. A petition that is a thousand pages long, versus one that is a hundred pages, means each individual page has a significantly lower chance of being read. We want to maximize the impact of every page of your filing.

My Professional Experience

In my practice, the number of recommendation letters often falls within a range:

• Typical Range: My successful cases typically include around six to eight recommendation letters.
• Larger Filings: Occasionally, for clients with particularly long or multifaceted careers, we might go beyond ten letters.

Leveraging Previous Petitions (e.g., O-1 Visas)

For clients who have previously filed O-1 petitions, we can often leverage that prior work for an EB-1A petition. This is a common and efficient strategy:

• Updating vs. Adding New Letters:
  • We might update an existing letter from a recommender to include your most recent career details and accomplishments.
  • Alternatively, we might use the same set of strong, existing letters and add a new recommender who can speak specifically to your latest achievements.
• Handling Older Letters and Dates: I generally don't discard good, relevant letters just because they were created for an earlier O-1 petition. If a letter is still strong and accurately reflects a significant aspect of your career, its original date doesn't bother me.
• One Letter Per Recommender Rule: I will only include one letter per person in a single filing. We won't ever have two letters from the same individual, even if they were written for different purposes or at different times.

Key Considerations for Your Recommendation Letters

Beyond the number, there are crucial details about the format and submission of your letters that can impact how USCIS perceives your evidence.

Signature Matters: The Power of a Hand-Signed Document

USCIS, across various petition types, consistently prefers hand-signed documents. This preference extends to your recommendation letters:

• Hand-Signed is Preferred: Even if your company or industry considers an electronic signature to be more secure or legally valid, USCIS generally views a physical, hand-signed "wet signature" as a higher evidentiary standard.
• No Electronic Signatures: Just like the forms you sign for your petition, recommendation letters should have an original, handwritten signature.

Physical Originals vs. Digital Scans: What USCIS Really Sees

Years ago, I loved the authenticity of including the actual physical recommendation letters. The different paper types, colors, and thicknesses felt so rich and genuine. It added a tactile, personal element to the filing. However, times have changed, and so has USCIS's processing:

• The "Sea Change": Many recommenders, especially those overseas or working remotely, find it challenging or impractical to mail physical letters. Offices are no longer universally set up for traditional mail.
• USCIS Scans Everything: When you submit your petition, USCIS physically scans every single document. Your beautiful original letter, complete with creases and unique paper, is immediately digitized. The adjudicator will not see your original physical document. All those intricate details are lost in the scanning process, and you don't even get to see the quality of the scan.
• Lost Communication Cues: In the past, attorneys used physical tools like highlighting, tabs, and colored paper to draw adjudicators' attention to key points. Much of this visual communication has become obsolete with digital scanning.

Optimizing Your Digital Submission: Beyond the Physical

Since USCIS will be viewing a scanned version of your letters, your focus should shift to optimizing the digital presentation:

• Scan Quality is Paramount: Ensure your letters are scanned at a very high resolution.
• Readability: Is the font clear and easy to read on a screen? Are any graphics or images large enough to be understood without straining?
• Logical Flow: Even though you can't use PDF bookmarks or tabs that the adjudicator will see, the internal logic and progression of your letters within the overall petition still matter. The goal is to make it as easy as possible for the adjudicator to navigate and understand your case, on a computer screen.

The Bottom Line: Quality Over Quantity

Ultimately, the power of your recommendation letters comes from their quality, not just their number.

Focus on:

• Compelling Storytelling: Each letter should contribute to the overarching narrative of your extraordinary abilities and achievements.
• Strategic Selection: Choose recommenders who can speak authoritatively and specifically about your unique contributions, especially those that align with the EB-1A or NIW criteria.
• High-Quality Production: Ensure your scanned letters are clear, legible, and include those crucial handwritten signatures.

Don't aim for an arbitrary number you think USCIS wants to see. Instead, focus on crafting a set of impactful letters that comprehensively and convincingly tell the story of your exceptional career.

---
Locke Immigration Law helps American businesses hire skilled foreign nationals to work in the United States.

Send us your information to see if we can help you.

Follow Loren Locke on LinkedIn

Watch Loren Locke on YouTube

---

Want to learn how to strategically frame your achievements for the EB1A "Extraordinary Ability" visa?

My free 5-day email course, "5 Days to Your Compelling EB1A Story," provides the 'EB1A Storytelling Toolkit' to help you build a powerful case.

Sign up here: https://lockeimmigration.com/eb1a-email-course