Understanding the Extraordinary Ability Green Card

---

The process to get an EB-1A petition approved and subsequently obtain a green card involves several steps, including preparing and filing the petition, providing comprehensive evidence of extraordinary ability, and completing the adjustment of status or consular processing. The EB-1A is part of the broader employment based immigrant visa category, which is an employment based immigrant visa for individuals with extraordinary ability, outstanding professors, researchers, and multinational managers. The EB-1A category is for foreign nationals with extraordinary ability in fields such as sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics, and it allows for self-petitioning without the need for employer sponsorship. The EB-1A is an extraordinary ability category within the first preference categories of employment-based immigration, and it allows for self petition by foreign nationals. This process is open to foreign nationals who meet the criteria. Consular processing typically includes an in person interview at a U.S. embassy or consulate.

In summary, the EB-1A is one of several extraordinary ability petitions available to foreign nationals seeking permanent residence through employment-based preference categories.

Eligibility Assessment

Initial Consultation: Begin with an initial consultation with an immigration attorney to assess eligibility for the EB-1A category. This involves evaluating the individual’s achievements and determining if they meet the criteria for extraordinary ability. During this consultation, the attorney will review the evidence submitted, such as awards, memberships, and peer recognition, and advise on how to strengthen such a petition to meet the high standards of the EB-1A category.

Preparation and Filing of Form I-140

Form I-140: The EB-1A petition is filed using Form I-140, Immigrant Petition for Alien Worker. This form can be filed with a designated USCIS service center.

Supporting Documentation: Provide documentary evidence that meets at least three of the ten criteria for extraordinary ability, such as awards, membership in associations, published material, and original contributions. Documentary evidence, including awards, publications, and letters, is critical to supporting the claims of extraordinary ability. The evidence must collectively demonstrate that the individual is among the top in their field.

Premium Processing

Expedited Processing: Premium Processing is available for EB-1A petitions, which guarantees a response from USCIS within 15 calendar days. This service requires an additional fee (currently $2805) and can expedite the decision-making process.

Adjustment of Status or Consular Processing

Adjustment of Status: If the individual is in the United States, they can file Form I-485, Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status, concurrently with or after the approval of Form I-140, provided a visa number is available.
Consular Processing: If the individual is outside the United States, they will go through consular processing at a U.S. embassy or consulate after the I-140 approval. This involves an interview and the issuance of an immigrant visa.

Green Card Issuance: Upon approval of the adjustment of status or successful consular processing, the individual will receive their green card, granting them lawful permanent residence in the United States.

The process to get an EB-1A petition approved and obtain a green card involves filing Form I-140 with comprehensive evidence of extraordinary ability, potentially using Premium Processing for expedited service, and completing either adjustment of status or consular processing. Each step requires careful preparation and documentation to meet the high standards of the EB-1A category.

EB1A Final Merits Determination

The final merits determination for an EB-1A I-140 petition is a critical step in the adjudication process where the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) evaluates whether the petitioner has demonstrated extraordinary ability in their field. This determination involves a comprehensive review of all submitted evidence to assess if the individual is among the small percentage at the very top of their field and has sustained national or international acclaim.

Two-Part Analysis: The EB-1A petition process involves a two-part analysis. First, the petitioner must meet at least three of the ten regulatory criteria or provide evidence of a one-time achievement of a major, internationally recognized award. Second, USCIS conducts a final merits determination to evaluate the totality of the evidence.

Kazarian Analysis: This analysis, stemming from the 2010 Kazarian case, requires USCIS to consider whether the evidence collectively demonstrates that the petitioner is among the top in their field. The Kazarian analysis adds an additional layer of scrutiny beyond meeting the initial criteria.

Subjectivity and Challenges: The final merits determination is often subjective and can be problematic, as seen in cases like Dr. Lum's, where meeting the regulatory criteria was not sufficient for approval. The USCIS must be convinced of the petitioner's international recognition and outstanding achievements.

Evidence Evaluation: USCIS evaluates all evidence in its entirety, considering both the quality and significance of the achievements. The petitioner must explain how the evidence demonstrates sustained national or international acclaim and recognition in their field.

Inconsistencies and Legal Precedents: There have been inconsistencies in how USCIS applies the final merits determination, leading to legal challenges. Courts have sometimes found USCIS's decisions arbitrary, highlighting the importance of clearly demonstrating extraordinary ability beyond just meeting the criteria.

Comparable Evidence: If the standard criteria do not apply, petitioners can submit comparable evidence. However, the application of such evidence can be inconsistent, affecting approval rates.

The final merits determination for an EB-1A I-140 petition is a nuanced process that requires demonstrating extraordinary ability through a comprehensive evaluation of evidence. Petitioners must not only meet the regulatory criteria but also convincingly show that they are at the top of their field. This process can be subjective and challenging, often requiring legal expertise to navigate successfully.

Evaluating Evidence for an EB1A Petition

Matter of Chawathe, 25 I&N Dec. 369 (AAO 2010), provides guidance on the evaluation of evidence, including recommendation letters, in immigration petitions. The decision emphasizes the importance of the quality, relevance, probative value, and credibility of evidence rather than the quantity alone. This principle applies to recommendation letters submitted as part of an immigration petition.

Quality Over Quantity

Matter of Chawathe establishes that the truth of a claim is determined not by the quantity of evidence alone but by its quality. This means that recommendation letters must be evaluated for their relevance, probative value, and credibility.

Evaluation of Recommendation Letters

Recommendation letters should provide detailed and specific information about the petitioner’s achievements and contributions. General praise without substantive details may not be sufficient to meet the evidentiary standard. The letters should explain how the petitioner’s work impacts their field and demonstrate the significance of their contributions. For example, evidence such as an international recognized award can be highly persuasive in establishing eligibility. Letters that lack this detail may not be persuasive in establishing eligibility.

USCIS’s Role

USCIS is responsible for making the final determination regarding a petitioner’s eligibility. While recommendation letters can support a petition, they are not presumptive evidence of eligibility. USCIS evaluates the letters based on their relevance, reliability, and overall probative value.

Matter of Chawathe highlights the importance of the quality and substance of recommendation letters in immigration petitions. The letters should provide detailed, specific, and credible information about the petitioner’s achievements and contributions to effectively support their case. Petitioners should ensure that their recommendation letters are well-documented and relevant to their field.

Navigating the complexities of U.S. immigration can be daunting, especially for individuals with exceptional talents and achievements. Among the various pathways to permanent residency, the Extraordinary Ability Green Card stands out as a unique opportunity for those who have demonstrated extraordinary ability in their fields. Whether you are an artist, scientist, athlete, business innovator, outstanding professor, multinational manager, or employed in a managerial or executive capacity, this visa category recognizes and rewards individuals who have reached the pinnacle of their professions. In this blog post, we will delve into the ins and outs of the Extraordinary Ability Green Card, exploring its eligibility criteria, application process, and the myriad benefits it offers. Additionally, we’ll address common challenges applicants face and provide strategies to strengthen your case. Join us as we unpack the essentials of this prestigious immigration option, equipping you with the knowledge needed to navigate your path to a new life in the United States.

The Extraordinary Ability Green Card, officially known as the EB-1A visa, is a unique immigration pathway designed for individuals who possess extraordinary ability in their respective fields. This visa is part of the Employment-Based Immigration First Preference category, which prioritizes individuals who demonstrate exceptional talent and achievements that set them apart from their peers. Unlike other employment-based visas such as EB-1B, the EB-1A category does not require a job offer or employer sponsorship, making it an attractive option for highly skilled individuals.

Extraordinary ability is defined by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) as a level of expertise indicating that the individual is among the small percentage of people who have risen to the top of their field. This can encompass a broad range of professions, including but not limited to:

Arts: Visual artists, musicians, actors, and filmmakers who have received significant recognition and accolades.
Sciences: Researchers, scientists, and academics who have made groundbreaking contributions to their fields.
Business: Entrepreneurs and business leaders who have achieved notable success and recognition in their industries.
Athletics: Exceptional athletes who have achieved national or international acclaim in their sports.
Academia and Management: Outstanding professors, multinational managers, and individuals employed in a managerial or executive capacity.

The Extraordinary Ability Green Card is crucial for individuals seeking to establish a long-term presence in the United States. It allows holders to live and work in the U.S. indefinitely, providing them the freedom to fully engage in their professional pursuits. Recipients of this green card become legal permanent residents of the United States. Furthermore, this visa category facilitates a smoother transition to permanent residency without the need for labor certification or employer sponsorship, which can often be cumbersome and time-consuming.

Who Should Consider Applying?

Individuals who may benefit from pursuing the Extraordinary Ability Green Card include:

Internationally recognized artists looking to expand their careers in the U.S. art scene.
Scientists and researchers who wish to collaborate with U.S. institutions, such as Harvard University or Stanford University, where innovation thrives.
Entrepreneurs with groundbreaking business ideas who want to tap into the vast U.S. market.
Athletes aiming for professional opportunities within leagues like the NBA or NFL, where competition is fierce and recognition is paramount.

The Appeal of the EB-1A Visa

The appeal of the EB-1A visa lies not only in its recognition of extraordinary talent but also in its expedited processing time and the flexibility it offers. With the right evidence and documentation, applicants can navigate the application process more swiftly than other visa categories, allowing them to focus on their careers and contributions to their fields.

In the following sections, we'll take a closer look at the eligibility criteria, the application process, the benefits associated with the Extraordinary Ability Green Card, and the common challenges that applicants may face. Understanding these aspects will empower you to make informed decisions as you embark on your journey toward obtaining this esteemed visa.

The eligibility criteria for the Extraordinary Ability Green Card (EB-1A) are stringent, reflecting the high standards set by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) to ensure that only those individuals who truly have extraordinary ability are granted this prestigious status. Below, we will explore the specific requirements and evidence needed to qualify for this visa category.

To qualify for an EB-1A visa, applicants must demonstrate extraordinary ability in their field. This is defined as possessing a level of expertise indicating that the individual is among the small percentage of people who have risen to the very top of their profession. This designation is not limited to a specific industry; it encompasses various fields, including:

Arts: Individuals who have received significant recognition for their artistic endeavors, such as awards, media coverage, or critical acclaim.
Sciences: Researchers and scientists who have made groundbreaking contributions to their disciplines, evidenced by publications, patents, or significant discoveries.
Business: Entrepreneurs and executives who have achieved remarkable success and recognition within their industries, often supported by awards, media features, or substantial financial metrics.
Athletics: Athletes who have achieved national or international recognition, including participation in prestigious competitions and receiving accolades for their performance.

Required Evidence

To prove extraordinary ability, applicants must provide substantial documentation that showcases their achievements and recognition in their field. USCIS requires at least three types of evidence from the following categories:

Awards and Honors: Recognitions received at a national or international level, such as:
Prestigious awards (e.g., Grammy, Oscar, Nobel Prize).
Industry-specific honors (e.g., a Pulitzer Prize for journalists).
Memberships in Professional Associations: Proof of membership in organizations that require outstanding achievements for admission, indicating that the applicant is among the top professionals in their field.
Published Material: Articles, papers, or books published about the applicant's work in professional or major trade publications, showcasing their influence and reputation.
Judging Others' Work: Evidence that the applicant has served as a judge of the work of others in their field, indicating recognition of their expertise.
Original Contributions: Documentation of significant contributions to the field, such as innovations, inventions, or research that have had a substantial impact.
High Salary: Evidence of a high salary or remuneration compared to others in the field, serving as an indicator of recognized ability.
Commercial Success: Proof of commercial success in the performing arts, such as box office receipts, sales figures, or other metrics indicating widespread acclaim.

Proving Sustained National or International Acclaim

In addition to the documentation outlined above, applicants must demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim. This means that their achievements are not only notable but have also been recognized consistently over time. This can be shown through:

A history of awards and recognitions received over several years.
Media coverage spanning various platforms, including news articles, interviews, and features.
Evidence of ongoing influence in their field, such as participation in conferences, panels, or expert discussions.

The application process for the Extraordinary Ability Green Card (EB-1A) is a critical step for individuals seeking to secure permanent residency in the United States based on their extraordinary talents. This process entails several key stages, from filing the initial petition to navigating potential requests for additional evidence. Below, we will provide a comprehensive overview of the application process, including essential steps and tips for a successful application.

Filing the Petition

Form I-140, Immigrant Petition for Alien Worker: The first step in the application process is to file Form I-140 with USCIS. This form serves as the petition for the EB-1A classification and must be accompanied by a robust collection of evidence demonstrating the applicant's extraordinary ability.
Supporting Documentation: Along with Form I-140, applicants must submit substantial documentation that meets the eligibility criteria outlined in the previous section. The evidence should clearly illustrate their accomplishments and sustained national or international acclaim. It is advisable to organize this evidence logically and coherently, with a cover letter summarizing the applicant's qualifications and achievements.
Filing Fees: As part of the application process, applicants must pay the required filing fees. As of October 2023, the fee for Form I-140 is typically around $700, but it is advisable to check the USCIS website for the most current fee information.
Premium Processing Option: Applicants have the option of selecting premium processing for an additional fee, which expedites the adjudication of the petition. If chosen, USCIS will process the I-140 petition within 15 calendar days, offering a quicker path to potential approval.

Awaiting Adjudication

Once the petition is submitted, applicants must wait for USCIS to adjudicate the I-140 petition. During this period, USCIS may take several actions:

Approval: If the petition is approved, the applicant will be notified, and they can proceed to the next steps in the immigration process.
Request for Evidence (RFE): In some cases, USCIS may issue a Request for Evidence if they require additional documentation to support the petition. This is a common occurrence, and applicants must respond promptly and thoroughly to address the concerns raised.
Denial: If the petition is denied, applicants will receive a notice outlining the reasons for the denial. Depending on the situation, applicants may choose to appeal the decision or refile the petition with additional supporting documentation.

Responding to Requests for Evidence

If an RFE is issued, applicants must carefully analyze the specific requests made by USCIS. To effectively respond:

Review the RFE Thoroughly: Understand what documentation or evidence USCIS is seeking. This may involve providing more detailed explanations, additional letters of recommendation, or clarifications about the applicant's contributions.
Gather Additional Evidence: Compile any new or supplementary evidence that strengthens the case. This may involve reaching out to colleagues or industry professionals for additional letters of support or gathering more recent publications or accolades.
Prepare a Comprehensive Response: Craft a well-organized response to the RFE, clearly addressing each point raised by USCIS. It is crucial to demonstrate how the additional documentation meets the eligibility criteria for the Extraordinary Ability Green Card.

Final Steps Post-Approval

Once the I-140 petition is approved, applicants can proceed to the next stages of obtaining permanent residency:

Adjustment of Status or Consular Processing: Depending on the applicant's current location, they may either file for Adjustment of Status (Form I-485) if they are already in the U.S. or undergo consular processing at a U.S. embassy or consulate if they are outside the country.
Form I-485, Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status: If adjusting status in the U.S., applicants must file Form I-485, along with any required documentation and fees. This process includes a biometrics appointment and potentially an interview.
Consular Interview: If pursuing consular processing, applicants will attend an interview at the designated U.S. embassy or consulate, where they will present their case and supporting documentation.
Receiving the Green Card: Upon approval of the I-485 application or consular processing, the applicant will receive their Green Card, granting them permanent residency in the United States.

The Extraordinary Ability Green Card (EB-1A) offers a myriad of benefits for individuals who have demonstrated exceptional talent and achievements in their respective fields. Securing this prestigious visa not only provides a pathway to permanent residency in the United States but also comes with unique advantages that can significantly enhance the professional and personal lives of the holders. In this section, we will explore the key benefits associated with the Extraordinary Ability Green Card.

Freedom to Live and Work in the U.S.

One of the most significant benefits of obtaining an EB-1A visa is the ability to live and work permanently in the United States. This freedom allows individuals to:

Pursue Career Opportunities: Holders can engage in various professional activities without being tied to a specific employer or job offer. This flexibility is particularly advantageous for artists, entrepreneurs, and scientists who may wish to explore multiple opportunities or collaborate on various projects.
Establish a Professional Network: Living in the U.S. provides access to a vast network of professionals in diverse fields, facilitating collaborations, partnerships, and mentorship opportunities. For instance, musicians may connect with industry leaders in Los Angeles, while scientists may collaborate with top researchers at institutions like the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).
Benefit from a Thriving Economy: The U.S. hosts one of the largest and most dynamic economies in the world, offering countless opportunities for growth and advancement in various sectors, including technology, finance, and the arts.

Potential for Expedited Processing

The EB-1A visa category is known for its expedited processing times compared to other employment-based immigration options. This expedited processing can be advantageous for several reasons:

Quick Path to Permanent Residency: Applicants can often receive a decision on their I-140 petition more quickly than those in other visa categories, such as the EB-2 or EB-3. By opting for premium processing, candidates can receive a decision within 15 calendar days, significantly reducing waiting times.
Reduced Backlogs: The EB-1A category typically has fewer applicants compared to other employment-based categories, leading to shorter wait times for immigrant visa availability. This is particularly beneficial for individuals from countries with high demand for U.S. visas, where backlogs can cause significant delays.

Unlike many other immigration pathways, the EB-1A visa does not require sponsorship from an employer or family member. This independence offers remarkable advantages:

Greater Autonomy: Applicants can pursue their professional interests without being tied to a specific employer. This independence is especially appealing to entrepreneurs and freelancers who may wish to start their own businesses or work on various projects.
Flexibility in Career Choices: Holders can change jobs or career paths without jeopardizing their immigration status, as long as they continue to engage in work that reflects their extraordinary ability. This flexibility allows for greater exploration of diverse interests and opportunities.
Avoiding Employer Dependency: By not requiring employer sponsorship, applicants eliminate the risks associated with employment-based visas, such as layoffs or job changes impacting their immigration status. This autonomy fosters a more secure and stable living situation in the U.S.

Pathway to Permanent Residency for Family Members

The EB-1A visa not only benefits the primary applicant but also extends advantages to family members:

Derivative Status for Family Members: Spouses and unmarried children under the age of 21 can obtain derivative status, allowing them to live and work in the U.S. alongside the primary applicant. This family unity is a significant consideration for many individuals seeking to relocate.
Potential for Future Green Card Applications: Once the primary applicant is granted a Green Card, family members may also become eligible for permanent residency. This can provide a sense of security and stability for families planning to make the U.S. their long-term home.

Opportunities for Naturalization

Upon holding the Green Card for a designated period—typically five years—EB-1A visa holders may be eligible to apply for U.S. citizenship through naturalization. This process offers several benefits:

Full Rights and Privileges: U.S. citizenship provides access to all rights and privileges granted to American citizens, including the ability to vote, run for public office, and obtain a U.S. passport.
Stability and Security: As a citizen, individuals gain a stronger sense of stability and security in their residency status, as they are no longer subject to the potential challenges associated with maintaining a Green Card.
Family Sponsorship Opportunities: U.S. citizens can more easily sponsor family members for immigration, expanding opportunities for loved ones to join them in the United States.

Common Challenges and Possible Solutions

While the Extraordinary Ability Green Card (EB-1A) offers a promising pathway to permanent residency for individuals with exceptional talent, the application process can present several challenges. Understanding these potential hurdles and preparing to navigate them effectively is crucial for a successful application. In this section, we will explore common challenges faced by applicants and provide practical solutions to address these issues.

For applicants considering the national interest waiver, it is important to demonstrate that their work has substantial merit and national importance, and that it serves the national interest of the United States. Highlighting the impact of his or her work on the field or on broader national interests can significantly strengthen the application.

Understanding the High Standard of Proof

One of the most significant challenges applicants encounter is the high standard of proof required to demonstrate extraordinary ability. USCIS requires substantial evidence that the applicant has achieved sustained national or international acclaim, which can be daunting for many.

Possible Solutions:

Comprehensive Documentation: Start by compiling a well-organized portfolio of evidence that clearly demonstrates your achievements. Consider including a variety of documentation, such as awards, publications, media coverage, and letters of recommendation from recognized experts in your field.
Consult a Qualified Immigration Attorney: Engaging an attorney experienced in EB-1A applications can provide invaluable guidance. They can help assess your qualifications, identify necessary evidence, and craft a compelling petition that meets USCIS standards.
Gather Letters of Recommendation: Obtain letters from industry leaders or professional organizations that articulate your extraordinary ability. These letters should detail your contributions, accomplishments, and the significance of your work within your field.

Building a Strong Case

Another challenge is effectively building a strong case that clearly articulates how you meet the requirements for extraordinary ability. Many applicants may struggle to present their achievements in a compelling manner.

Possible Solutions:

Tailored Evidence Submission: Customize your evidence to highlight your unique contributions and accomplishments that set you apart from others in your field. Focus on quality over quantity, ensuring that each piece of evidence directly supports your claims.
Highlight Your Impact: Emphasize the significance of your achievements by showcasing their impact on your industry or community. For example, if you are a scientist, include metrics or data demonstrating how your research has influenced advancements in your field.
Narrative Approach: Consider including a personal statement or cover letter that provides context for your achievements. This narrative can help USCIS better understand your journey, the challenges you've overcome, and the significance of your contributions.

Addressing Potential Pitfalls

The application process can also be fraught with potential pitfalls, including incomplete documentation, errors in forms, or misunderstandings about eligibility criteria. These issues can lead to delays or denials.

Possible Solutions:

Thorough Review: Before submitting your application, conduct a thorough review of all documentation and forms to ensure accuracy and completeness. Double-check that all required evidence is included and that forms are filled out correctly.
Stay Informed: Regularly check for updates on USCIS policies and procedures related to the EB-1A visa category. Understanding current guidelines can help applicants avoid common mistakes and pitfalls.
Prepare for Possible RFEs: Anticipate that USCIS may issue a Request for Evidence (RFE) and be ready to respond promptly and comprehensively. Having additional evidence prepared in advance can streamline the response process if needed.

Managing Emotional and Psychological Challenges

Navigating the application process can also be emotionally taxing. The uncertainty and potential for rejection can create stress and anxiety for many applicants.

Possible Solutions:

Maintain Perspective: Remind yourself of the reasons you are pursuing the EB-1A Green Card and the potential opportunities it can bring. Keeping your long-term goals in mind can help alleviate some of the pressure.
Seek Support: Connecting with others who have gone through the process or seeking support from friends, family, or professionals can provide encouragement and guidance. Consider joining forums or support groups for applicants in similar situations.
Practice Self-Care: Engage in activities that promote well-being and reduce stress. Whether through mindfulness practices, exercise, or pursuing hobbies, taking care of your mental health is essential during this journey.

Conclusion

While the application process for the Extraordinary Ability Green Card can present various challenges, being aware of these hurdles and implementing proactive solutions can significantly enhance your chances of success. By understanding the high standards of proof, building a strong case, addressing potential pitfalls, and managing the emotional aspects of the journey, applicants can approach the EB-1A application process with confidence. With careful preparation and determination, individuals with extraordinary ability can achieve their goal of permanent residency in the United States, paving the way for a bright future filled with opportunities.

---
Locke Immigration Law helps American businesses hire skilled foreign nationals to work in the United States.

Follow Loren Locke on LinkedIn at https://www.linkedin.com/in/lorenlocke/

Watch Loren on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCzKOZDiSIwLEFidGISrxX_Q

Book a consultation at https://calendly.com/locke-immigration/strategy-call

Contact us at hello@lockeimmigration.com

---

Want to learn how to strategically frame your achievements for the EB1A "Extraordinary Ability" visa?

My free 5-day email course, "5 Days to Your Compelling EB1A Story," provides the 'EB1A Storytelling Toolkit' to help you build a powerful case.

Sign up here: https://lockeimmigration.com/eb1a-email-course