Can EB2 be Upgraded to EB1: A Comprehensive Guide

Get there faster.

The U.S. immigration system allows individuals to pursue multiple immigration pathways simultaneously. This means a person can have multiple I-140 petitions filed on their behalf in different categories, such as EB-2 and EB-1, as long as they meet the eligibility criteria for each category.

Multiple I-140 Petition Filings

There is no regulatory limit on the number of I-140 petitions that can be filed for a single beneficiary, by one or more petitioners (or self-petitioned where possible). An individual can have both an EB-2 and an EB-1 petition filed concurrently or sequentially.

EB-2: Typically for professionals with advanced degrees or individuals with exceptional ability. It may require a labor certification unless applying for a National Interest Waiver (NIW).
EB-1: Includes subcategories such as extraordinary ability, outstanding professors or researchers, and multinational executives or managers. Each subcategory has specific criteria that must be met.

Priority Dates

The priority date from an approved I-140 petition can be retained and applied to any subsequent I-140 petitions filed on behalf of the same beneficiary. This can be advantageous if the priority date is earlier than the current date for the new category.

Strategic Considerations

Filing in multiple categories can be a strategic decision to increase the chances of obtaining a green card, especially if one category has longer retrogression or delays. It is important to ensure that each I-140 petition is supported by the necessary documentation and evidence to meet the specific requirements of the category.

An individual can have both an EB-2 and an EB-1 I-140 petition without conflict, as long as they meet the eligibility criteria for each category. The ability to retain the priority date from an earlier petition can be beneficial in expediting the process.

Upgrading to EB-1

An EB-2 I-140 petition cannot be directly "upgraded" to an EB-1 I-140 petition. Instead, a new EB-1 I-140 petition must be filed, meeting the specific requirements for the EB-1 category. Here is a detailed analysis of the process:

The EB-2 and EB-1 categories are distinct employment-based immigrant visa classifications, each with its own set of eligibility criteria. The EB-2 category is generally for professionals holding advanced degrees or individuals with exceptional ability, while the EB-1 category includes subcategories such as extraordinary ability (EB1A), outstanding professors or researchers (EB1B), and multinational executives or managers (EB1C).

Eligibility Requirements

EB-1A (Extraordinary Ability): Requires evidence of extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics through sustained national or international acclaim. No job offer is required.
EB-1B (Outstanding Professors and Researchers): Requires international recognition for outstanding achievements in a particular academic field, with at least three years of experience in teaching or research in that area. A job offer from a U.S. employer is required.
EB-1C (Multinational Executives and Managers): Requires employment with a qualifying organization outside the U.S. in a managerial or executive capacity for at least one year in the three years preceding the petition. A job offer from a U.S. employer is required.

Filing a New I-140 Immigrant Petition

A new Form I-140 must be filed for the EB-1 category. This is not an amendment or upgrade of the existing EB-2 petition but a separate filing that must independently meet all EB-1 requirements. Supporting documentation must be provided to demonstrate eligibility under the chosen EB-1 subcategory.

Priority Date Consideration

The priority date from the approved EB-2 I-140 can often be recaptured and applied to the new EB-1 I-140 petition. This can be beneficial if the priority date is earlier than the current date for the EB-1 category.

To transition from an EB-2 to an EB-1 category, a new I-140 petition must be filed under the EB-1 category, meeting all specific eligibility criteria. The priority date from the EB-2 petition can typically be retained, which may expedite the process if the priority date is favorable.

Navigating the complex landscape of U.S. immigration can be a daunting task, especially for skilled professionals seeking to enhance their career opportunities through employment-based visas. Among the various visa categories, the EB2 and EB1 classifications stand out as two of the most sought-after pathways for foreign nationals aiming to secure permanent residency in the United States. While the EB2 visa is designed for professionals with advanced degrees or exceptional abilities, the EB1 visa is reserved for individuals who demonstrate extraordinary ability in their field, outstanding professors and researchers, or certain multinational executives and managers.

For many individuals currently holding an EB2 visa, the question arises: Can I upgrade to an EB1? This comprehensive guide aims to demystify the process of upgrading from EB2 to EB1, exploring the legal framework, eligibility criteria, and common scenarios that may warrant such a transition. We will also delve into the procedural steps required for the upgrade, potential challenges you may encounter along the way, and strategies to navigate these hurdles effectively.

Whether you are contemplating an upgrade or simply seeking to understand the nuances of these visa categories, this guide will provide you with the insights and information necessary to make informed decisions about your immigration journey. Join us as we unpack the complexities of moving from EB2 to EB1 and unlock the potential for greater career advancement in the United States.

Understanding the Basics: EB1 and EB2 Visa Categories

When navigating the U.S. immigration system, understanding the different visa categories is crucial for prospective immigrants. The EB1 and EB2 visa classifications are two vital pathways that enable skilled individuals to gain permanent residency based on their professional qualifications and achievements. In this section, we will explore the fundamental characteristics of each visa category, their eligibility requirements, and the benefits they offer to applicants.

What is the EB1 Visa?

The EB1 visa category is designed for individuals who possess extraordinary abilities in their respective fields, along with outstanding professors and researchers, and certain multinational executives and managers. The EB1 visa is further divided into three subcategories:

EB1A: Extraordinary Ability
This subcategory is for individuals who can demonstrate extraordinary ability in the arts, sciences, education, business, or athletics. Applicants must provide evidence of sustained national or international acclaim and achievements that are recognized in their field. Notably, EB1A applicants do not require a job offer or employer sponsorship, allowing for greater flexibility in their immigration journey.
EB1B: Outstanding Professors and Researchers
The EB1B visa is intended for professors and researchers who have at least three years of experience in teaching or research and are recognized internationally in their academic fields. To qualify, applicants must provide evidence of significant contributions to their areas of expertise and typically need a job offer from a U.S. university or research institution.
EB1C: Multinational Managers and Executives
This subcategory is aimed at managers and executives who have been employed outside the U.S. for at least one year within the last three years by a related entity. The applicant must be entering the U.S. to continue working in a managerial or executive capacity for the same employer or a subsidiary.

What is the EB2 Visa?

The EB2 visa category is designed for professionals who hold advanced degrees or possess exceptional abilities in their fields. Similar to EB1, the EB2 visa has two main subcategories:

Advanced Degree Professionals
This subcategory is for individuals holding an advanced degree (master’s or higher) or its equivalent, which is defined as a bachelor’s degree plus five years of progressive work experience in the field. Applicants must demonstrate that their expertise is critical for the U.S. labor market.
Exceptional Ability
Individuals who can demonstrate exceptional ability in the arts, sciences, or business may qualify under this subcategory. Unlike the EB1A visa, which requires extraordinary ability, the EB2's exceptional ability standard is slightly less stringent.

Key Differences Between EB1 and EB2

Eligibility Criteria:
The primary difference between EB1 and EB2 lies in the level of achievement required. EB1 applicants must demonstrate extraordinary ability, whereas EB2 applicants can qualify through advanced degrees or exceptional ability.
Job Offer Requirement:
For EB1A applicants, a job offer is not necessary, while EB1B and EB1C applicants typically require employer sponsorship. In contrast, EB2 applicants generally must have a job offer unless they qualify for a National Interest Waiver (NIW), which allows them to self-petition.
Processing Time and Backlogs:
EB1 visas often have shorter processing times and are less likely to face backlogs compared to EB2 visas, which can be subject to longer wait times due to higher demand, particularly for applicants from countries with significant immigration populations, such as India and China.

Benefits of EB1 Over EB2

Choosing the EB1 path over EB2 can offer several advantages:

No Labor Certification Required: EB1 applicants (particularly in the EB1A category) are exempt from the labor certification requirement, which can streamline the application process.
Faster Processing Times: Due to lower demand, EB1 visas often have quicker processing times, allowing successful applicants to achieve permanent residency sooner.
Flexibility in Employment: EB1A applicants do not need employer sponsorship, providing the freedom to change jobs or start their own ventures without jeopardizing their immigration status.

In summary, understanding the fundamental differences between the EB1 and EB2 visa categories is essential for any foreign national considering a move to the United States. With a clear grasp of the eligibility criteria, benefits, and processes involved, applicants can make informed decisions about which pathway aligns best with their professional aspirations and personal circumstances. As we delve deeper into the topic of upgrading from EB2 to EB1, this foundational knowledge will serve as a crucial reference point.

EB2 to EB1 Upgrade: Is it Possible?

As skilled professionals navigate their journeys in the U.S. immigration system, the prospect of upgrading from an EB2 visa to an EB1 visa is a topic of significant interest. Many individuals currently holding an EB2 visa are often curious about the possibility of transitioning to the more prestigious EB1 category, which can offer a faster path to permanent residency and fewer restrictions. In this section, we will explore whether it is possible to upgrade from EB2 to EB1, examine the legal framework supporting this transition, and clarify the eligibility criteria that must be met.

Understanding the Legal Framework

The U.S. immigration system allows for the possibility of upgrading visa categories, including moving from EB2 to EB1. This upgrade is not an automatic process; rather, it necessitates a thorough evaluation of an applicant's qualifications and achievements. The ability to upgrade is governed by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) regulations and guidelines, which outline the requirements for both EB2 and EB1 categories.

The legal basis for upgrading primarily hinges on the applicant's ability to demonstrate that they meet the eligibility criteria for the EB1 category in question, whether it be EB1A, EB1B, or EB1C. It is essential to note that the applicant’s circumstances and achievements must align with the specific requirements of the EB1 category they are targeting.

Eligibility Criteria for Upgrade

To successfully upgrade from EB2 to EB1, applicants must satisfy the eligibility requirements specified for the EB1 visa category:

For EB1A (Extraordinary Ability):
The applicant must demonstrate extraordinary ability in their field through sustained national or international acclaim.
Evidence can include significant awards, publications, membership in prestigious organizations, and recognition by peers in the field.
The applicant does not require a job offer or employer sponsorship to file for EB1A.
For EB1B (Outstanding Professors and Researchers):
The applicant must have at least three years of experience in teaching or research in their academic field.
They must provide evidence of international recognition for their contributions to the field.
A job offer from a U.S. university or research institution is typically required.
For EB1C (Multinational Managers and Executives):
The applicant must have been employed outside the U.S. for at least one year within the last three years in a managerial or executive capacity.
They must be entering the U.S. to continue working in a managerial or executive role with the same employer or a related entity.

Common Scenarios for Upgrade

Several scenarios may prompt an EB2 visa holder to consider upgrading to EB1:

Significant Professional Achievements: If an individual has attained notable accomplishments or recognition in their field since receiving their EB2 visa, they may qualify for EB1A.
Change in Employment Status: An EB2 holder employed as a researcher may transition to a professorship at a prestigious university, making them eligible for the EB1B category.
Career Advancement: Individuals who have moved into managerial or executive positions in multinational companies may find themselves eligible for the EB1C upgrade.
Pursuit of National Interest Waiver (NIW): Those who initially applied under the EB2 category with a National Interest Waiver may be able to demonstrate that their work has gained substantial recognition, allowing them to transition to EB1.

While the upgrade from EB2 to EB1 is indeed possible, it is essential for applicants to meticulously assess their qualifications and achievements against the EB1 criteria. In doing so, they can determine whether pursuing an upgrade is a viable option that aligns with their professional trajectory and immigration goals.

As we continue through this guide, we will delve deeper into the process of upgrading, the documentation required, and the potential challenges one may face along the way. Understanding these elements will empower applicants to navigate the transition more effectively and increase their chances of success.

Process of Upgrading from EB2 to EB1

Upgrading from an EB2 visa to an EB1 visa can be a strategic move for individuals seeking to enhance their immigration status in the United States. This process, however, requires careful planning and a clear understanding of the necessary steps involved. In this section, we will outline the specific process for upgrading from EB2 to EB1, including the preparation of documentation, filing procedures, and what to expect after submitting the application.

Preparing the Necessary Documentation

The first step in the upgrade process is to gather and prepare the required documentation that demonstrates eligibility for the EB1 visa category. Depending on whether the applicant is pursuing EB1A, EB1B, or EB1C, the documentation requirements will vary. Here’s a breakdown of what to prepare for each subcategory:

For EB1A (Extraordinary Ability):
Evidence of Extraordinary Ability: Applicants must compile evidence showing sustained national or international acclaim. This may include:
- Major awards (e.g., Nobel Prize, Academy Awards)
- Membership in associations that require outstanding achievements
- Published articles or books that highlight the applicant’s contributions
- Media coverage and recognition in industry publications
- Letters of recommendation from experts in the field attesting to the applicant's extraordinary ability
Personal Statement: A detailed personal statement outlining the applicant's career achievements, contributions to their field, and the impact of their work.
For EB1B (Outstanding Professors and Researchers):
Evidence of Academic Accomplishments: Applicants should gather proof of their teaching or research experience, including:
- Documentation of teaching positions held at universities or colleges
- Evidence of research contributions, such as published papers and citations
- Recognition from peers, including awards or grants
Job Offer: A job offer letter from the U.S. institution confirming the applicant's position as an outstanding professor or researcher.
For EB1C (Multinational Managers and Executives):
Evidence of Employment: Applicants must provide documentation proving their employment with a multinational organization, including:
- Job descriptions that highlight managerial or executive responsibilities
- Organizational charts showing the applicant's position within the company
- Letters from employers confirming the duration and nature of employment
Job Offer: A letter from the U.S. employer outlining the managerial or executive role the applicant will assume upon entering the U.S.

Filing for the Upgrade

Once all necessary documentation has been prepared, the next step is to file the application for the EB1 visa. The process for filing generally involves the following:

Complete the Form I-140: The primary form for filing an employment-based immigration petition is Form I-140, Immigrant Petition for Alien Worker. This form must be completed accurately, reflecting the applicant's eligibility for the EB1 category.
File with USCIS: Submit the completed Form I-140, along with all supporting documentation, to the appropriate USCIS service center. The filing fee must also be included. Depending on the applicant's situation, they may choose to file under premium processing for expedited review.
Wait for USCIS Response: After submission, USCIS will provide a receipt notice confirming the receipt of the petition. Processing times can vary significantly based on the service center and workload, so applicants should be prepared for varying wait times.

Expectations After Filing

After filing for the upgrade from EB2 to EB1, applicants should be aware of what to expect during the processing period:

Request for Evidence (RFE): In some cases, USCIS may issue a Request for Evidence if they need additional information or clarification regarding the application. Applicants should respond promptly and thoroughly to any RFEs to avoid delays.
Approval or Denial: Once the review process is complete, USCIS will notify the applicant of the decision. If approved, the applicant will receive an approval notice, which can lead to a subsequent application for adjustment of status (Form I-485) or consular processing for an immigrant visa.
Transition to EB1: If the upgrade is approved, the applicant’s immigration status will transition from EB2 to EB1, granting them the benefits associated with the EB1 category, including eligibility for expedited processing and reduced restrictions on employment.

In conclusion, upgrading from EB2 to EB1 requires meticulous preparation and adherence to USCIS guidelines. By understanding the documentation needed, filing procedures, and the expected timeline, applicants can navigate this process more effectively and maximize their chances of a successful transition to the EB1 visa category. As we proceed, we will explore potential challenges that may arise during this upgrade process and strategies for overcoming them.

Potential Challenges and How to Overcome Them

Upgrading from an EB2 visa to an EB1 visa can be a promising opportunity for many professionals, but the process is not without its challenges. Navigating the U.S. immigration system requires thorough preparation and an understanding of the potential obstacles that applicants may encounter along the way. In this section, we will discuss common challenges faced during the upgrade process and provide strategies for overcoming them.

Overcoming the Backlog Issue

One of the most significant challenges for EB2 and EB1 applicants, particularly from countries with high demand for U.S. immigration, such as India and China, is the visa backlog. This can lead to long wait times for processing and approval.

Strategies to Overcome the Backlog: 1. Monitor Visa Bulletin: Regularly check the U.S. Department of State's Visa Bulletin to stay informed about current priority dates and visa availability. Understanding the movement of priority dates can help applicants gauge when they might expect to proceed with their application.

Consider Premium Processing: For EB1A and EB1B petitions, applicants have the option to use premium processing, which expedites the processing time to approximately 15 calendar days for an additional fee. While this does not guarantee approval, it can significantly reduce wait times.
Explore Concurrent Filing: If eligible, consider filing Form I-485 (Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status) concurrently with Form I-140 to streamline the process, allowing applicants to adjust their status while the I-140 petition is being processed.

Dealing with the Extraordinary Ability Standard

For EB1A applicants, meeting the standard of "extraordinary ability" can be one of the most challenging aspects of the upgrade process. This standard requires substantial documentation and evidence of national or international acclaim.

Strategies to Build a Strong Case: 1. Gather Comprehensive Evidence: Focus on compiling a robust portfolio of evidence that clearly highlights your achievements. This can include awards, media articles, endorsements from industry experts, and records of significant contributions to your field.

Obtain Strong Letters of Recommendation: Solicit letters from recognized experts in your field who can attest to your extraordinary ability. These letters should detail specific accomplishments and provide context on your impact within the industry.
Professional Guidance: Consider hiring an immigration attorney experienced in EB1 cases. They can help assess your qualifications against the extraordinary ability standard and provide guidance on how to effectively present your case.

Navigating the Uncertainty of USCIS Decisions

The subjective nature of immigration decisions adds another layer of uncertainty to the upgrade process. USCIS adjudicators have broad discretion in evaluating petitions, leading to potential inconsistencies in decision-making.

Strategies to Mitigate Uncertainty: 1. Thorough Preparation: Ensure that your application is meticulously prepared, with all required documents and evidence clearly organized. A well-documented application can help alleviate concerns regarding approval.

Stay Informed: Keep abreast of changes in USCIS policies and guidelines that may impact the evaluation of EB1 petitions. Understanding current trends can help you tailor your application to align with USCIS expectations.
Prepare for Possible RFEs: Be ready for the possibility of receiving a Request for Evidence (RFE). If an RFE is issued, respond promptly and comprehensively, addressing all inquiries and providing additional supporting documentation as needed.

In conclusion, while the journey from EB2 to EB1 may present various challenges, understanding these potential obstacles and implementing effective strategies can enhance the likelihood of a successful upgrade. By proactively addressing the backlog issue, navigating job offer requirements, meeting the extraordinary ability standard, and preparing for USCIS decisions, applicants can position themselves for success in their pursuit of permanent residency in the United States. As we continue through this guide, we will explore the important topic of EB2 to EB1 porting and its associated benefits.

Addendum: EB2 to EB1 Porting

As skilled professionals navigate the complexities of U.S. immigration, the concept of porting from EB2 to EB1 presents a compelling opportunity for those seeking to enhance their immigration status and secure permanent residency. In this section, we will elucidate the process and benefits of EB2 to EB1 porting, as well as the circumstances under which it may be applicable.

Understanding EB2 to EB1 Porting

Porting refers to the ability of an immigrant to switch or upgrade their immigration petition from one employment-based category to another. In this context, EB2 to EB1 porting allows individuals who originally qualified for an EB2 visa to transition to the EB1 category, provided they can demonstrate eligibility under the EB1 criteria.

This process is particularly relevant for individuals who have made significant advancements in their careers since their initial EB2 approval. For example, an EB2 holder who has gained considerable recognition in their field may find that they now meet the extraordinary ability standard required for EB1A or have secured a prestigious academic position that qualifies them for EB1B.

How to Port from EB2 to EB1

Assess Eligibility: The first step in the porting process is to evaluate whether you meet the eligibility criteria for the EB1 category. This assessment should focus on your professional achievements, recognition, and contributions to your field.
Gather Required Documentation: As with the upgrade process, applicants must compile comprehensive evidence to support their EB1 petition. This may include:
Awards and recognitions
Publications and citations
Letters of recommendation
Documentation of professional roles and responsibilities
File Form I-140: To initiate the porting process, you will need to file Form I-140 (Immigrant Petition for Alien Worker) for the EB1 category, accompanied by the necessary documentation. If you are currently in the U.S. and your priority date is current, you may file for adjustment of status concurrently using Form I-485.
Notify USCIS of Intent to Port: If you are currently in the process of an EB2 application and wish to port to EB1, it is advisable to notify USCIS of your intent to switch categories. This can help ensure that your case is appropriately assessed under the criteria for EB1.

Benefits of EB2 to EB1 Porting

Enhanced Immigration Status: Transitioning to the EB1 category can provide a more favorable immigration status. EB1 visas generally have shorter processing times and are less likely to face backlogs, allowing for a faster pathway to permanent residency.
Increased Flexibility: EB1A applicants have the advantage of not requiring employer sponsorship, offering them greater flexibility in employment opportunities. This can be particularly advantageous for individuals who wish to change jobs or start their own ventures without jeopardizing their immigration status.
Reduced Requirements: The EB1 category often has fewer requirements compared to EB2, particularly regarding labor certification and job offers. This can simplify the immigration process for eligible individuals.
Recognition and Prestige: Successfully obtaining an EB1 visa can enhance an applicant's professional standing and recognition within their field, potentially opening doors to further career advancements and opportunities.

Conclusion

Porting from EB2 to EB1 represents a significant opportunity for eligible individuals seeking to improve their immigration status in the United States. By understanding the porting process and rigorously evaluating one's qualifications, applicants can make informed decisions that align with their professional goals.

In summary, the journey from EB2 to EB1 involves navigating a multifaceted process that includes assessing eligibility, preparing documentation, and understanding the benefits of porting. With careful planning and strategic execution, individuals can enhance their prospects for success in their pursuit of permanent residency in the U.S. As the landscape of immigration continues to evolve, being well-informed and prepared will be key to achieving your immigration objectives.

---
Locke Immigration Law helps American businesses hire skilled foreign nationals to work in the United States.

Follow Loren Locke on LinkedIn at https://www.linkedin.com/in/lorenlocke/

Watch Loren on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCzKOZDiSIwLEFidGISrxX_Q

Book a consultation at https://calendly.com/locke-immigration/strategy-call

Contact us at hello@lockeimmigration.com

---

Want to learn how to strategically frame your achievements for the EB1A "Extraordinary Ability" visa?

My free 5-day email course, "5 Days to Your Compelling EB1A Story," provides the 'EB1A Storytelling Toolkit' to help you build a powerful case.

Sign up here: https://lockeimmigration.com/eb1a-email-course